Written by 
Madewell The Greta Ballet Flat ($98)
Between the subtle square toe, buttery soft leather, and stretchy strap, these flats are the perfect mix of modern and classic, and are available in four different colors. They even won the heart of our editor, who tested them out and was surprised that they didn’t require a breaking-in period. For more details, check out our Madewell The Greta Ballet Flat review.
Editor quote: “Aside from their blister-free fit, there are other small details in the shoe’s design that I really appreciate. The shoe features a squared toe with slightly rounded edges, so they simultaneously manage to feel fresh yet timeless. The toe is also elongated beyond where my toe naturally ends (very ballerina-like!), which keeps my feet from looking short and stubby. I can see the smallest bit of toe cleavage peeking out, which also tricks the eye, making my feet appear longer and somehow slimmer.” — Angela Elias, contributing editor, Shopping