UK, New Zealand, and Colombia join coalition to phase out fossil fuel subsidies
An announcement has just come through that the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and Colombia have joined the international Coalition on Phasing Out Fossil Fuel Incentives Including Subsidies (COFFIS).
COFFIS is a Dutch-led coalition of governments working together to remove barriers and facilitate transparency toward the phase-out of fossil fuel subsidies. It now has 16 member countries, including Austria, the federal government of Antigua and Barbuda, Belgium, Canada, Colombia, Costa Rica, Denmark, Finland, France, Ireland, Luxemburg, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Spain, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.
And the members have now committed to coming to COP30 with a national plan for phasing out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies.
Responding to the announcement from the UK, Rebecca Newsom, Senior Political Advisor at Greenpeace UK, said:
“The UK’s decision to join this coalition is another indication that British climate diplomacy is finally coming out of its slumber after several dormant years under the Tories. Further collaboration around tackling fossil fuel subsidies can only be a good thing.
“But given G7 and G20 leaders have repeatedly signed statements over many years to tackle this issue, now is the time for real action. UK fossil fuel production subsidies are worth billions every year. These should be redirected immediately, alongside extra taxes on the fossil fuel industry, to unlock cash to deliver on the UK’s climate finance obligation to support developing countries.
“It’s time to make polluters pay for the climate damages they have caused.”
Key events
Negotiators are still mulling over how on earth to get the money on the table. Josh Gabbattiss of Carbon Brief writes on Bluesky that one possible option being explored is that of “voluntary contributions”.
EU climate chief Wopke Hoekstra said yesterday that a “potential solution” could be to “move into a space of voluntary contributions.”
Hoekstra said “with affluence comes responsibility”, suggesting countries classed as “developing” should pay as well as “developed” nations. “Yet I do recognise that for countries it is typically difficult to leave entrenched positions and move officially from one category to the next.”
This certainly feels like one of the biggest stumbling blocks in the discussions now. Gabbatiss points out:
The thing is, countries like China already give a lot of money that could be called climate finance – but isn’t, under the UN system. Deciding that this money does in fact count, in some way, would increase climate-finance totals overnight.
Hundreds of lobbyists for industrial agriculture are attending the Cop29 climate summit in Baku, analysis shows, writes Rachel Sherrington for the Guardian.
They include representatives from some of the world’s largest agribusiness companies including the Brazilian meatpacker JBS, the animal pharmaceuticals company Elanco, and the food giant PepsiCo, as well as trade groups representing the food sector.
Overall, 204 agriculture delegates have accessed the talks this year, analysis by DeSmog and the Guardian reveals. While the total number has dropped compared with the record highs at Cop28, the figures show climate Cops remain a top priority for businesses working in agriculture, a sector that accounts for up to a third of global greenhouse gas emissions.
Food sector lobbyists remain highly influential, and have travelled to Baku as part of country delegations from Brazil, Russia and Australia, among others. This year, nearly 40% of delegates travelled to the summit with country badges, giving them privileged access to diplomatic negotiations, up from 30% at Cop28, and just 5% at Cop27.
Read more at the link below:
Good morning (or afternoon if you’re in Baku). Bibi van der Zee here, taking over from my esteemed colleague Damien Gayle, for the rest of the day.
Please send your thoughts and suggestions to Bibi.vanderzee@theguardian.com. Thanks!
The public relations company Teneo, of which Tony Blair was a founding advisor, has been paid $4.7m by Azerbaijan to manage publicity around Cop29, according to research.
The UK-based climate justice group Energy Embargo for Palestine have published research linking Blair with Teneo and Azerbaijan’s climate summit, and pointing out the deep involvement of both in supporting fossil fuel projects.
In the caption to their Instagram post they write:
What does Tony Blair have to do with a PR consultancy that managed the PR of 2 petrostates hosting COP 2 years in a row? Hear us out.
This Teneo deep dive reveals to us how integrated agents of fossil-based capitalism and imperialism are with one another. It shouldn’t come as a shock that Tony Blair was on the founding advisory board for a PR firm that makes fortunes covering up colonial climate crimes. It shouldn’t come as a shock that Tony Blair’s think tank is advising on COP29’s climate negotiations, despite Blair’s role in lobbying for BP ahead of the invasion of Iraq. It shouldn’t come as a shock that Azerbaijan has chosen BP’s former PR manager and spin doctor Geoff Morrell’s company to polish their greenwashing.
We know that the corporate and state actors fuelling the genocide of Palestinians rely on an innocuous public image. This public image is crafted and curated by firms like Teneo. When we question and challenge the accounts of fossil fuel companies, we are challenging the accounts of spin doctors like Teneo.
Dharna Noor
At Cop29 today, I ran into Katie Rood, the New Zealand footballer, writes Dharna Noor, US fossil fuels and climate reporter. Rood came to the summit to speak on a panel about the role of athletes in the climate fight.
Last month, Rood led an open letter demanding FIFA drop the oil giant Saudi Aramco as a sponsor on humanitarian and environmental grounds. The partnership is “a middle finger to women’s soccer,” the letter said.
“The sponsorship doesn’t align with the values of the sport and Fifa’s own values,” she said.
Rood was thrilled with the letter’s reception. It was signed by 130 athletes and received international media coverage. Fifa’s response, however, was underwhelming.
“Fifa just kind of came back with a blank statement about how much they value their sponsorship and that they’re investing in women’s football,” she said. “So we haven’t heard directly from them about it.”
Over 1,700 coal, oil and gas lobbyists granted access to Cop29, the Guardian revealed last week.
“It’s disturbing to see just how much influence the lobbies have here,” Rood said. “Are we actually able to have influence and make positive steps toward a brighter future?”
Right now, there is a “tug of war going on between different entities,” Rood said.
“But I think we just have to keep putting our best foot forward,” she said.
A European negotiator at Cop29 responding to the G20 communique has told AFP: “We were waiting for a boost. Our expectations were maybe too high.”
As reported earlier, the G20 leaders at a summit in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, last night issued a communique that reaffirmed their commitment to the transition away from fossil fuels, but was fuzzy about the sources of finance that are needed for developing countries to fund their transition and adaptation.
Developing countries, which are the least responsible for global greenhouse gas emissions, want an annual commitment of $1.3tn, and they want the money to come from public grants financed by richer countries.
Developed nations, facing their own debt problems and budget deficits, say the private sector must play a key role in climate finance.
“The reality of the situation is that 1.3 trillion pales in the face of the seven trillion that is spent annually on fossil fuel subsidies,” Fiji’s deputy prime minister, Biman Prasad, told Cop29 delegates.
“The money is there. It is just in exactly the wrong place,” he said.
US congressman accuses Azerbaijan of attempted assault
A US congressman has accused Azerbaijan’s government of organising an attempted assault on him while he visited Baku.
On his return to Washington on Monday, representative Frank Pallone, who is an outspoken supporter of Azerbaijan’s rival Armenia, told reporters that he was only saved by the diplomatic security he was travelling with.
“It was no question that if it wasn’t for the fact that security that the embassy hired protected me, I would have been in the hospital,” he was quoted as saying by AFP.
The Democrat from New Jersey said he was confronted by hostile and seemingly coordinated questions by local media while visiting Cop29.
Around 50 “thugs” then waited for him outside his hotel, with the local police refusing to take him through a back entrance but the US embassy-provided security shielding him, he said.
“It was clear that they wanted to assault me,” he said, adding: “You know this was orchestrated by the government. That’s what this was all about. In order to make a point that we don’t want you here and we don’t want you articulating concerns that you have.”
Democrat senator Ed Markey said he also encountered harassment while in Baku, and that he needed a bodyguard even inside his hotel.
Markey, who is a leading climate advocate, accused energy producer Azerbaijan of intensifying repression and “greenwashing” both its climate and human rights record by holding Cop29.
“We can’t just allow these authoritarian petrostates to ignore both the human rights and the climate threats that have to be addressed in a comprehensive way,” Markey said.
Dharna Noor
On food, agriculture and water day at Cop29, US officials trumpeted the Biden administration’s conservation wins, writes Dharna Noor, US fossil fuels and climate reporter, in Baku.
Shortly after taking office, Biden set a goal to conserve at least 30% of US lands and waters by 2030.
“I’m proud to say that we have conserved more than 45 million acres so far,” said Brenda Mallory, chair of the White House council on environmental quality, in a Tuesday press conference.
The US secretary of agriculture, Thomas Vilsack, also spoke, touting the the intergovernmental Agriculture Innovation Mission (AIM) for Climate initiative, led by the US and UAE.
At Cop29, the initiative announced $29.2bn in funding for resilient agriculture and food systems globally.
Asked how the Biden administration’s efforts on environmental justice can be preserved under Donald Trump, Mallory noted that many dollars have “already gone out to communities” for everything from closing off leaky oil and gas wells to swapping gas-fuelled school buses with electric ones.
Under Biden, the Environmental Protection Agency also took several steps to improve water quality and rein in toxic chemical pollution, including by implementing water limits for toxic forever chemicals and lead, she noted.
“Some of those will surely continue,” she said.
But Trump is expected to re-evaluate many of these rules and regulations.
When the Guardian asked Vilsack how the administration can preserve its legacy on conservation, he said funding has already been spent to do so, with contracts signed and partnerships formed.
“So I’m confident that this is going to continue, just because I think the people who are receiving the benefits understand it’s their responsibility to preserve it,” he said. “Theres a groundswell of momentum that I don’t think any administration…would be in a position to stop”
Damian Carrington
Yesterday delegates in Baku heard from youth representatives, who spoke about the ways in which they were being affected by climate breakdown. Here’s one we didn’t have a chance to run earlier.
“As a surfer, I’m constantly on the ocean, and I actually felt the oceans warming,” says Catarina Lorenzo, 17, a professional surfer from Salvador, in Bahia state in Brazil.
Lorenzo is one of the Unicef climate youth advocates at Cop29, representing the future of humanity, writes Damian Carrington, Guardian environment editor. She said:
My family has always taught me the importance of taking care of nature, and they always say that taking care of nature is taking care of ourselves.
When I look at Brazil this year, we see that the climate consequences are getting worse and worse. We saw floods in the South, droughts in the Amazon, burning of the Pantanal, the destruction of the Cerrado, which became the most destroyed biome of Brazil.
We have droughts in the rainy seasons, and this affects the small family farms and because of this, the big agricultural and livestock industry buys the land from the small agricultural community and then contribute more to the climate crisis.
How can children access their rights to a safe, healthy and clean environment if they don’t have the natural spaces to access. When my government throws sewage in the river, it goes to the ocean, and I can’t surf because I’m going to get sick.
As a surfer, I’m constantly on the ocean, and when I was nine years old, I actually felt the oceans warming. The water was much hotter than normal, and when I got close to a coral reef, it was full of white spots. That is coral bleaching, something that had never happened.
Children have things to say [but] we need the space to say it. We need a Cop for children. When I get into the position of power where the older generation is now, I won’t have the same power to make effective actions. The actions have to be made now. If we are the future, then this future needs to have a voice.
The UN climate change body the UNFCCC has published a video on Instagram about the interrelationships between climate breakdown and education.